Gary Neville warns Pochettino not to trust a United bounce
Reacting to Michael Carrick's sacking, Neville recalls a Tottenham whiteboard that showed how firmly Pochettino could draw the line on recruitment.
No. 56 on the daily chartNo. 6 on the Sports chart
Why this story? One of the most watched videos since yesterday, with 705,913 views.
Gary Neville gives IMMEDIATE reaction to Manchester United sacking Michael Carrick
Next story: Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
9 more stories on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino ›
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:11Neville expresses sadness at Carrick's departure and describes United's position in the relegation zone.
- 0:57He criticises the club hierarchy's indecision and handling of the dismissal.
- 3:35He questions recruitment spending and the defensive players assembled.
- 5:19Neville warns that an initial improvement under Pochettino must not obscure the need for squad changes.
- 6:00A Tottenham whiteboard memory illustrates Pochettino's clear distinctions between players to retain and move on.
- 10:50Neville calls for a defensive rebuild and identifies Mainoo as his standout midfield exception.
Gary Neville's warning to Manchester United's possible next manager is about what might happen if results improve. An early bounce, he argues, must not persuade Mauricio Pochettino to abandon the squad changes the club needs.
His Sky Sports Premier League reaction to Michael Carrick's sacking drew about 706,000 views since yesterday. Neville begins with sadness at his former team-mate's departure, describing United as being in the relegation zone, before directing his criticism towards the people making the decisions above the manager.
"It's a really poor poor reflection upon the decision-makers," he says of the handling of Carrick's exit.
The most revealing passage comes when the conversation turns to Pochettino, whose appointment remains a possibility rather than a confirmed arrival. Neville remembers visiting him at Tottenham and seeing a whiteboard separating players he wanted to retain from those he wanted to move on. His point is that Pochettino would need that same clarity at United, and firm backing to improve the defence in January.
Neville runs through the difficulties experienced by David Moyes, José Mourinho, Louis van Gaal and Erik ten Hag. Changing the person in charge, in his account, has repeatedly failed to settle the deeper problems.
By the closing squad assessment, his prescription is substantial: rebuild the back line and make extensive changes elsewhere, with Kobbie Mainoo his standout midfield exception. Viewers are discussing much the same question in the comments: what can another manager change if the players remain the same?
Published on Trari
More on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino
Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
Goldbridge on Carrick's exit: sympathy isn't a case to stay
Gary Neville tallies United's 11 managers in 13 years as Pochettino nears
All stories on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino ›
Where next?
What do you think?
- Channel
- Sky Sports Premier League
- Subscribers
- 6,060,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 19,694,467
- Channel views, pace per day
- 1,040,473 (on a normal day: 2,786,495)
- Video published
- November 12, 2026
- Video views so far
- 705,913 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 894,709
The numbers
Neville's reaction drew a substantial audience, while the comments have already passed four times the channel's usual first-day total.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which French club has Mauricio Pochettino managed?
Pochettino managed Paris Saint-Germain from 2021 to 2022.


