Goldbridge on Carrick's exit: sympathy isn't a case to stay
The United Stand host accepts the dismissal but argues that another managerial change cannot repair the decisions above the dugout.
Why this story? One of the most watched videos since yesterday, with 502,121 views.
Carrick Sacked! Goldbridge Man Utd News
Next story: Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
9 more stories on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino ›
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:00Goldbridge announces Carrick's dismissal and says removing him is the correct decision.
- 1:14He cites United's bottom-three position and one win in ten to challenge arguments for keeping Carrick.
- 3:57He recalls opposing a permanent appointment after Carrick's interim spell.
- 8:00He argues that assembling coaches and executives without shared working experience has undermined United's direction.
- 12:16He asks chat about United's outlook and doubts the leadership can deliver title contention.
Mark Goldbridge draws a line between feeling for Michael Carrick and wanting him to remain Manchester United manager. In his reaction to the dismissal, the distinction is blunt: "I can say it's sad for an individual to be sacked; I can't say it's wrong for him to be sacked."
The United Stand's monologue drew about half a million views since yesterday. This time, unlike the sarcastic sacking announcement we reported here earlier in the week, Goldbridge opens by saying Carrick has officially gone.
He calls it the correct decision, citing United's position in the bottom three and a run of one win in ten matches. He also challenges suggestions that supporters broadly wanted Carrick to stay, recalling his own doubts about turning the interim appointment into a permanent one.
But accepting the dismissal isn't the same as endorsing the people making it. Goldbridge questions squad choices and selections, then turns to Sir Jim Ratcliffe's approach to assembling coaching and executive teams. His complaint is that United keep putting together people without an established working relationship and expecting a coherent football operation to follow.
The argument goes beyond whether the next manager can improve the scorelines. "Results without performance and vision lands you here," he says. By the closing discussion with chat, his concern is whether the club's leadership can build a side capable of challenging for titles at all.
Published on Trari
More on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino
Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
Gary Neville warns Pochettino not to trust a United bounce
Gary Neville tallies United's 11 managers in 13 years as Pochettino nears
All stories on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino ›
Where next?
What do you think?
- Channel
- The United Stand
- Subscribers
- 2,320,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 9,251,921
- Channel views, pace per day
- 1,314,987 (on a normal day: 1,513,180)
- Video published
- November 12, 2026
- Video views so far
- 502,121 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 561,203
The numbers
The reaction passed half a million views before its first full day was over. Comments were already several times above the channel's usual first-day total.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which Portuguese club did Rúben Amorim manage immediately before Manchester United?
Amorim moved from Sporting CP to Manchester United in 2024.


