Gary Neville tallies United's 11 managers in 13 years as Pochettino nears
Stick to Football recorded the eve of Michael Carrick's exit, with Roy Keane, Jamie Carragher, Jill Scott and Ian Wright weighing what any new manager would inherit.
No. 17 on the daily chartNo. 2 on the Sports chart
Why this story? One of the most watched videos since yesterday, with 1,326,742 views.
Carrick Out, Pochettino In. Can Anybody Save Man United? | Stick to Football EP 157
Next story: Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
9 more stories on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino ›
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:54Before the show starts, Neville recalls Salford City winning the EFL Trophy against Portsmouth at an empty Wembley.
- 8:19Neville expects Carrick to lose his job and Pochettino to replace him.
- 10:45Neville calls United's back four probably the worst in the league, citing errors against Aston Villa.
- 17:21Neville explains Pochettino's demanding fitness focus and asks how this squad would cope.
- 28:15Neville sets out his figures: 11 managers in 13 years, £1.6 billion on players, £1.2 billion of debt.
- 42:48The panel agree Pochettino would need defensive signings in January; Neville says otherwise he shouldn't take the job.
Gary Neville comes to the table with a ledger, not a theory. Eleven managers in 13 years, £1.6 billion spent on players, £1.2 billion of debt and infrastructure he describes as crumbling: that, he argues, is the Manchester United Mauricio Pochettino would be walking into.
The Stick to Football episode was recorded while Michael Carrick was still in the job. "All things are pointing towards Michael Carrick will lose his job tomorrow," Neville says, adding that he thinks United are "finalizing the deal with Pochettino as we speak." About 1.3 million people have watched it since yesterday, and the comments came in more than six times faster than on the channel's usual first day. The episode is sponsored by Disney+.
The football comes first. Neville calls United's defence "probably the worst back four in the Premier League" and points to mistakes in the recent match against Aston Villa. Carragher says the squad doesn't look physically at the level of other Premier League teams. Keane boils it down to work without the ball: "It's what you do out of possession. That's the key." That makes Pochettino an interesting fit, because Neville says the Argentine puts physical fitness "really at the top of the agenda".
Then the panel turn to the club itself. Neville criticises the owners for handling Carrick's dismissal from a meeting in Monaco rather than in Manchester, and says they lack the cash to support a successful team. His condition for Pochettino is blunt: defensive signings in January. "They have to give it to him, or else he shouldn't take the job." Scott, for her part, believes Carrick "will bounce back".
Many viewers joke about how much of every episode goes to United. The show does give time to Manchester City's midfield and mood, and the whole table agrees that Jayden Bogle's challenge on Mathys Tel deserved yellow, not red. Neville also recalls the FA Cup tie at Anfield where a Michael Owen tackle left him with ten stitches in his ankle, which Carragher is happy to discuss.
Published on Trari
More on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino
Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
Goldbridge on Carrick's exit: sympathy isn't a case to stay
Gary Neville warns Pochettino not to trust a United bounce
All stories on Manchester United's agreement with Pochettino ›
Where next?
What viewers say
The Overlap stats-
Man United talk: 80%
Man City 115 charges: 10%
“Are Arsenal boring?” 8%
Every other team in the league: a few seconds during super 6 predictions.@MrReeealistSee it on YouTubeCan’t wait for November 2027 when we decide if Conte is the answer as Poch failed to deliver
@zainsarwat8125See it on YouTubeThink we should rename the podcast Groundhog Day, just united talk over and over again
@Jsmiddy408See it on YouTube
6 more comments
the 4th rendition of the united pod on the overlap!
@sonny2k753See it on YouTubeGreat to hear a fresh subject matter being talked about
@samdobson7665See it on YouTubeI hope Manchester United Football Club is talked about. Not heard anything about them in 22 Minutes
@Admiral_99See it on YouTubeMan united have spent more on managers in the last 10 years than my club has spent in total in its existence 😅
@adamboow8299See it on YouTubeAs if they've still got Carrick going into Carrington to take training while they're off signing a new manager. It's a joke.
@54321djgSee it on YouTubeUtd's problem in the last few years was the gaping hole in midfield, but Casemiro had an unexpectedly brilliant season. Now, back to square one
@JeffVenndiagramSee it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
- Channel
- The Overlap
- Subscribers
- 1,810,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 6,170,017
- Channel views, pace per day
- 956,537 (on a normal day: 1,241,407)
- Video published
- November 12, 2026
- Video views so far
- 1,326,742 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 1,434,572
The numbers
The comment section stands out: viewers wrote several times more comments than on a usual first day for the show.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which club co-owned by Gary Neville won the EFL Trophy at an empty Wembley, as he recalls in the episode?
Neville recalls Salford City beating Portsmouth in the EFL Trophy final, played at Wembley behind closed doors during lockdown.


