Scholes asks whether United have left Pochettino too late
The Good, The Bad & The Football moves into Ireland's Apple Podcasts top 100 as its emergency episode weighs experience against another fresh start.
Why this story? The podcast "The Good, The Bad & The Football" rose to #86 on Apple's podcast chart in Ireland, from #156 yesterday.
POCH IN, CARRICK OUT? | GBF EMERGENCY POD 🚨
Next story: Carrick departs United, with Pochettino's arrival awaiting US fixtures
50 more stories on Manchester United ›
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:40Butt says poor results make a managerial change necessary despite his affection for Carrick.
- 3:12Scholes reviews Pochettino's coaching history and questions whether United have waited too long to appoint him.
- 6:17Butt identifies communication and a disciplined squad environment as Pochettino's strengths.
- 20:12Scholes objects to Carrick conducting training while reports circulate about an agreement with his replacement.
- 22:18Scholes prefers Conte's shake-up; Butt argues Pochettino better suits a squad needing long-term rebuilding.
Paul Scholes can see the appeal of Mauricio Pochettino at Manchester United. His reservation is the timing: "My only slight concern is, have we come a little bit too late to the party?"
That question sits at the centre of The Good, The Bad & The Football's emergency episode, as the show rises from 156th to 86th on Apple's podcast chart in Ireland. It is the podcast's highest position there in the past month.
Made by Platform Media and hosted by Scholes, Nicky Butt and Paddy McGuinness, the show combines former players' dressing-room experience with a comedian's questions. Its recent conversations have included James Nelson-Joyce's Liverpool childhood and Lisandro Martinez's sending-off against Chelsea. This time, reports of Michael Carrick's impending replacement bring the hosts together outside their regular Monday schedule.
Scholes questions whether Pochettino can reproduce the impact of his earlier coaching years, but also argues that United need someone with authority over the whole football operation. Butt puts more weight on the prospective manager's communication and ability to build a disciplined environment.
Their different preferences become clearest near the end. Scholes would have chosen Antonio Conte to shake things up. Butt prefers Pochettino because he believes United need patient construction rather than a short, explosive cycle. For him, the squad is not yet ready to win, whoever takes charge.
The episode is sponsored by a betting app. Alongside the coaching debate, it returns to Carrick taking training while reports of an agreement with his replacement circulate, a situation Scholes calls disrespectful.
Published on Trari
More on Manchester United
Where next?
What do you think?
- Subscribers
- 190,000 ▲ 1,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 1,532,093
- Channel views, pace per day
- 478,789 (on a normal day: 281,754)
- The podcast
- The Good, The Bad & The Football
- Place on the chart today
- 86
- Place on the chart yesterday
- 156
- Best place in the last 30 days
- 86
- Video published
- November 11, 2026
- Video views so far
- 159,550 (2 days online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 130,477
The numbers
The podcast's climb takes it to its best Irish chart position of the past month.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which club gave Mauricio Pochettino his first managerial job in English football?
Pochettino became Southampton manager in January 2013 before moving to Tottenham in 2014.





