Kevin Smith builds ChefSteps' steak and Guinness pie from scratch
The Beast & Cleaver butcher gives the gravy its own attention, then seals the beef inside a hot-water-and-lard crust.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 51,165 views a day, 7.8 times a normal first day on this channel (6,570).
How a Master Butcher Makes the Ultimate Steak and Guinness Pie
Next story: ChefSteps turns button mushrooms into shaveable "Truffaux"
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:52Smith makes hot water crust pastry with lard, then wraps and rests the dough.
- 2:20Chuck beef is seared, combined with aromatics, Guinness and stock, then braised in the oven.
- 6:31The strained braising liquid becomes gravy, reduced with more Guinness and seasoned with sherry vinegar.
- 8:07Smith shreds the beef and adjusts the filling's texture and moisture before cooling it.
- 10:56Pastry-lined springform molds hold the filling; separate lids are crimped and vented.
- 15:08The pies bake at 375°F, then 350°F, before cooling slightly for unmolding.
Gravy isn't an afterthought. Kevin Smith strains the beef's braising liquid, reduces it with more Guinness and seasons it with sherry vinegar. Some of that richness binds the filling; more goes over the pie when it's cut open.
His ChefSteps tutorial has drawn roughly 42,000 views in its first sixteen hours, putting it on course for nearly eight times the channel's usual first-day audience. The Seattle butcher and restaurateur, introduced as "The Pie Piper," takes the recipe from dough to the final gravy pour.
The beef is chuck, seared before an oven braise with aromatics, stout and stock. But tenderness is only part of the job. Smith separates the cooked meat from its liquid and adjusts the filling's moisture before cooling it, giving the pastry something substantial to hold rather than a loose stew.
For the casing, he makes hot water crust pastry with lard, rests it, then rolls separate bases and lids. The pies take shape in springform molds, with crimped crowns and vents. "They're all slightly different and that's kind of the beauty of these," he says.
Viewers are getting into the construction details: one asks why the base is rolled out rather than formed directly in the mold, while another considers substituting a dark Dutch bock for the Guinness. Nick joins Smith for the slicing and tasting, after a background appearance that has one commenter imagining him circling for a bite.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Food on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
In my mind, Nick in background is just a shark waiting and circling to get a bite.
@MightyEumendiesSee it on YouTubeLooks great! The lard and hot water in a dough is new for me and the rich gravy looks inviting. I might try it with a dark Dutch bock beer though 😃
@jan_van_dam_67See it on YouTubeWhat is the thinking behind rolling out the bottom crust before putting it in the springform? With a narrower, taller mold, it seems like you could save yourself the trouble of dealing with the overhang by just forming it in the pan. And you can actually do it in a reasonable amount of time since the pan is so much smaller than a regular-sized circular pan.
@svfrey7See it on YouTube
2 more comments
Love Kevin’s food. Meat pies are OP.
@satanismybrotherSee it on YouTubeWell done this the best vid from chef steps I’ve seen in a long time. I guess I’m just a fan of the fine tuned classics great work.
@tonyg168See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- ChefSteps
- Subscribers
- 1,380,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 705,556
- Channel views, pace per day
- 125,569 (on a normal day: 59,279)
- Video published
- November 15, 2026
- Video views so far
- 42,453 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 51,165
The numbers
Smith's pie tutorial is heading toward a much stronger first day than a typical ChefSteps upload. The first-day estimate below is a projection, not a completed day's total.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which cut of beef does Kevin Smith use for the pie filling?
Smith sears chuck beef before braising it with aromatics, Guinness and beef stock.


