Curt Cignetti's CFP complaint meets Heather Dinich's close-wins argument
ESPN College Football's fast-starting Short puts Indiana's results, rather than its coach's credentials, at the center of the rankings debate.
Curt Cignetti isn't shy about his thoughts on the CFP rankings 😬
Up next
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 88,600 views a day, 11 times a normal first day on this channel (8,119).
15 more stories on College Football Playoff ›
"Bad losses don't count anymore?" Curt Cignetti asks in a social media post shown by ESPN. Heather Dinich's answer turns the attention to Indiana's wins, and how difficult some of them have been.
The Indiana coach's criticism of the College Football Playoff rankings anchors a commentary Short that reached roughly 66,000 views in 13 hours, already far beyond ESPN College Football's usual first-day Shorts audience. Its comment section is unusually busy, too, with more than thirty times the channel's usual first-day comments.
Dinich points to close games against Michigan, Minnesota and Northwestern, along with special-teams struggles, as reasons to question Indiana's position. She makes a deliberate distinction between the coach and his team: "He is a great coach. He's the best coach in the country, but this might not be the best team in the country..."
Cignetti's post also uses clown emojis. Dinich notes that four former head coaches sit on the selection committee, making the symbols themselves part of the panel's response.
The comments raise a more substantive question: how much should being tied or behind at halftime matter if a team ultimately wins? Others ask why Alabama sits above Tennessee or argue that making the playoff matters more than the ranking along the way.
ESPN has also posted a separate Paul Finebaum response to Cignetti and Indiana, drawing an above-usual early audience of its own. The coach's brief post has supplied material for more than one panel discussion.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Sports on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
I didn't realize trailing/being tied at the half is now factored into the rankings
@Gobucks1998-1See it on YouTubeWhy is Bama above Tennessee?
@GurpreetSingh-dj9enSee it on YouTubeDon't worry about the ranking. If you get in, show you're the better team.
@Pnk_RckrSee it on YouTube
2 more comments
He's not saying they are the best team in the nation he just doesnt get how he drops so far on a bye week.
@stickfigureproductsSee it on YouTubeThis "Ranking Criteria" has gotten out of control.
@MarkRussell-j5zSee it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- ESPN College Football
- Subscribers
- 1,440,000 ▲ 10,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 26,362,921
- Channel views, pace per day
- 4,605,512 (on a normal day: 3,520,491)
- Video published
- November 17, 2026
- Video views so far
- 65,578 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 88,600
The numbers
The Cignetti discussion has already exceeded the channel's usual full-day Shorts views, with an even larger jump in comments.
💡 Test your knowledge
What does CFP stand for in college football?
CFP is the abbreviation for the College Football Playoff, whose rankings Cignetti is questioning.


