Pat McAfee makes the case for a 24-team playoff
The Week 12 rankings drew nearly eight times the usual first-day comments on The Pat McAfee Show, even though views were typical.
The Latest College Football Playoff Ranking Is The Most Controversial Ever?!
Up next
Why this story? The video drew 1,205 comments in its first day, 7.9 times a normal first day on this channel (152).
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:36McAfee singles out two-loss Alabama's placement above unbeaten UCLA.
- 2:57Schmit argues the committee gives SEC teams too much credit and discounts Iowa's recent run.
- 5:04McAfee explains how the committee ranks teams in groups and why he thinks that produces odd placements.
- 7:28McAfee says someone who doesn't vote, such as Rich Clark, should explain the committee's decisions.
- 12:35McAfee proposes a 24-team playoff to give more underdogs a postseason chance.
- 22:09Schmit says he accepts the automatic bid rule because it was in place from the start.
Two-loss Alabama sits above unbeaten UCLA on the College Football Playoff rankings board, and Pat McAfee doesn't have to look far for another objection. Ty Schmit, wearing his Iowa gear, argues that the committee gives SEC teams too much credit and overlooks the run his Hawkeyes have put together.
Viewers brought their own comparisons to the comment section. Some questioned why teams with four losses were still ranked while New Mexico was left out. One Oklahoma supporter even thought the committee had been too generous to the Sooners. Others wanted the old computer rankings back.
McAfee's answer is a bigger bracket. He walks through how the committee ranks teams in groups, then puts a hypothetical 24-team field on screen. His argument is that a wider field would give more underdogs a chance to settle it on the field instead of leaving their seasons at the mercy of a committee vote.
Schmit does come around on one part of the existing format. When McAfee asks whether Boise State's rise could put it in position for an automatic bid, the Iowa supporter says he can live with that rule, even if it costs a team on the bubble. Everyone knew it going in.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Sports on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
I'm a big OU fan but I have to admit, no matter how bad the team is, the committee always seems to give them generous chances to make the playoffs.
I'm not complaining but being ranked 20th with 4 losses seems too generous.@CNSCNSCNS-t2rSee it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- The Pat McAfee Show
- Subscribers
- 3,000,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 6,217,792
- Video published
- November 18, 2026
- Video views so far
- 408,775 (2 days online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 246,366 (on a normal day: 373,287)
The numbers
About 1,200 comments came in during the segment's first day. Here's how that compares with the show's usual start.
💡 Test your knowledge
Where did Pat McAfee play college football?
McAfee kicked and punted for the West Virginia Mountaineers.


