CarExpert asks whether your next ute should be a truck
Paul Maric loads an Isuzu light truck and a Ranger Super Duty with concrete, then finds different reasons to choose each.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 148,750 views a day, 5.7 times a normal first day on this channel (26,115).
Don't buy a ute until you watch this! Isuzu truck vs Ranger Super Duty off-road!
Next story: CarExpert's Mazda CX-6e test hits a software snag
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:00Both vehicles carry roughly a tonne of concrete, making load handling central to the comparison.
- 1:07The Isuzu pairs a nine-speed dual-clutch transmission with a weight rating suitable for a standard Australian car licence.
- 10:19The turning-circle comparison shows the Isuzu can turn more tightly than the Ranger Super Duty.
- 16:04On corrugated gravel, Maric finds the Isuzu more comfortable and composed than he expected.
- 22:13Engaging front-axle drive lets the Isuzu crawl across humps that stopped it in rear-wheel drive.
- 22:55Maric favours the Isuzu for worksite load carrying and value, but the Ranger for extreme off-roading.
The load is identical. Paul Maric puts a tonne of concrete aboard both an Isuzu NMS light truck and a Ford Ranger Super Duty, then takes them onto sealed roads, corrugated gravel and worksite-style terrain. The question is whether buyers asking more of a ute should be looking at a truck instead.
CarExpert's comparison drew about 142,000 views before its first day was over, running at nearly six times the channel's usual first-day pace for regular videos. Off-road comparisons are familiar territory here: its most-watched regular upload puts a dozen medium SUVs through their paces. This time, the unexpected alternative has a commercial truck cab.
"I'm not a truck expert, I'm a car expert," Maric says as he gets behind the Isuzu's wheel. Its dual-clutch transmission impresses him with its responsiveness, while the suspended driver's seat and composure over corrugations challenge his expectations of truck comfort. The Isuzu also turns in a tighter circle than the Ranger.
The rough-ground test gives that argument a practical demonstration. The truck loses rear-wheel traction on cross-axle humps, then crawls over after Maric engages drive to the front axle.
His verdict isn't that everyone should abandon the ute. He recommends the Isuzu for tradespeople prioritising tray space, load carrying and rough worksites, while choosing the Ranger for extreme off-roading. He also gives the truck the nod for value and daily driving comfort.
Viewers are testing that proposition against life beyond the worksite: some imagine a camper on the tray, others want a double-cab comparison for family use. Several ask for a fuel-consumption comparison, another practical question for this unusually loaded shopping decision.
Published on Trari
Where next?
What viewers say
But the Isuzu might not fit into the KFC drive thru. New testing criteria?
edit: I take it back, we can park it in the parking area, no KFC lost@unahbsSee it on YouTubeMake a camper in the tray, ditch the van.😅
@perpetualgrin5804See it on YouTubeIt would have been great to compare with a double cab truck instead to see how they stack up as a weekend family vehicle, given thats why dual cab utes sell so well.
@shaunanderson8282See it on YouTube
3 more comments
New proving ground, same flies mate.
@theregistrar6334See it on YouTubeHow does fuel economy compare?
A big question not answered..@BradWolff-f1zSee it on YouTubeNever mind, comparing a super duty I have been looking at one of these flatbed commercials in place of a Ute for the last couple of years. It absolutely makes sense.
@TopendterrificSee it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
- Channel
- CarExpert
- Subscribers
- 689,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 956,470
- Channel views, pace per day
- 122,109 (on a normal day: 138,294)
- Video published
- November 12, 2026
- Video views so far
- 142,285 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 148,750
The numbers
The truck-and-ute test is drawing views much faster than CarExpert's usual regular upload. Its first day was still underway at the totals shown here.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which manufacturer makes the Ranger Super Duty?
The Ranger Super Duty is Ford's heavy-duty ute tested alongside the Isuzu NMS.


