Scott Manley examines Super Heavy's tower abort and green flare
His fast-starting Short separates the reported reason for abandoning the tower catch from what happened just above the water.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 955,272 views a day, 27 times a normal first day on this channel (35,719).
Why Did SpaceX's Superheavy Booster Not Return To Tower?
Next story: Moon-base plans meet air-show spectacle on Scott Manley's Florida trip
The upper stage reached orbit, but the booster's return ended with crumpling metal and an explosion above the Gulf. Scott Manley's breakdown looks closely at that split outcome, asking why Super Heavy headed for the water rather than back to its launch tower.
"Why Did SpaceX's Superheavy Booster Not Return To Tower?" drew about 920,000 views in its first 22 hours, far beyond the usual start for one of his Shorts. It follows his explainer on Starship's "flip and burn" maneuver, moving from how a landing should work to the clues left when one does not.
Manley describes reported communications trouble between the tower and booster as the reason for the wave-off. That is a separate question from why the booster subsequently collapsed. Wider ground footage shows the descent over water, followed by what he identifies as activation of the flight termination system.
For the final moments of engine operation, he directs attention to a brief green flare after the orange exhaust. He interprets it as a sign of oxygen-rich burning and possible fuel depletion, rather than presenting it as a confirmed diagnosis. His conclusion is that the booster appears to have exhausted its fuel to the point where its engines could no longer fire.
The comments pick up on the tank crumpling and the changing exhaust, alongside a distinctly earthbound joke: perhaps the rocket only needed a car-style diagnostic scan and its fault codes cleared.
Published on Trari
A professional in this field? Want to write about Science & learning on Trari? Tell us ›
Where next?
What viewers say
They just forgot to plug diagnostics into OBD2 and clear fault codes.
@bojnedSee it on YouTubeThats crazy to see that massive tank crumple in seconds.
@min10StudiosSee it on YouTubeWhy am I not surprised that you already have a video out?🤣
@sixstringsimpletonSee it on YouTube
1 more comment
Great summary thanks Scott!
@philipmumford7871See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- Scott Manley
- Subscribers
- 1,870,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 1,564,648
- Channel views, pace per day
- 236,732 (on a normal day: 266,306)
- Video published
- November 14, 2026
- Video views so far
- 922,633 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 955,272
The numbers
The Short's views and comment count both climbed far beyond Scott Manley's usual first-day levels for this format.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which fuel do SpaceX's Raptor engines burn with liquid oxygen?
Raptor engines use liquid methane as fuel and liquid oxygen as the oxidizer.


