More
Video taking off 24x its usual first day

Smosh explains the Werewolf game with no werewolves

The Mashable interview drew about 39,000 views in 14 hours, and commenters were already pitching the cast's next game.

Smosh Cast Reacts to Their Iconic "Oops! All Villagers!" Werewolf PrankSmosh Cast Reacts to Their Iconic "Oops! All Villagers!" Werewolf Prank
What did you think?

Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 51,883 views a day, 24 times a normal first day on this channel (2,139).

Spencer Agnew and producer Alex Tran didn't have to tell the Smosh cast to act suspicious. They just had to let everyone assume somebody else had drawn the werewolf card. In a game where the villagers are supposed to root out a liar, giving everyone the same role was enough to get them second-guessing one another.

Agnew takes credit with Tran for the prank in Mashable's "Smosh Cast Reacts to Their Iconic "Oops! All Villagers!" Werewolf Prank." The interview was already well past what a regular Mashable upload usually draws in a full day. And when reporter Belen Edwards turns to the mansion-set version of the game, there's a neat reversal: Tommy Bowe really is the werewolf, and his strategy is to say as little as possible. "And I am so deeply guilty and silent!" he says, watching himself back.

For another game on that scale, Amanda Lehan-Canto picks the more intricate Blood on the Clocktower. Bowe would rather take Smosh Pit Theater into a deep cave and read comments there. Viewers had location ideas of their own, including hide-and-seek in a haunted house, while one was reminded of Smosh's old live-action Among Us videos.

Mashable also got an unusually quick start for a Short with a question from the same interview: Who takes over as Smosh's best liar after Arasha Lalani's departure? Bowe's answer doesn't leave much room for nominations. "I don't think anyone will ever take Arasha's place."

Published on Trari

Where next?

Things we can learn from the video

Press to jump

  1. 0:00Amanda Lehan-Canto and Tommy Bowe explain the prank: every player got a villager card.
  2. 0:48Smosh Games director Spencer Agnew says he and producer Alex Tran came up with the all-villager setup.
  3. 3:10In the mansion game, Bowe was the werewolf and kept quiet to avoid giving himself away.
  4. 4:27Lehan-Canto wants an immersive Blood on the Clocktower; Bowe jokes about reading comments in a cave.
  5. 6:02Bowe says he doesn't think anyone will take Arasha Lalani's place.

A professional in this field? Want to write about Comedy & challenges on Trari? Tell us ›

What viewers say

  • Wherewolf in real life made me think of the Among Us in real life videos they did several years ago, in the Mythical studio.
    @JDubbsTheatreSee it on YouTube
  • Arasha mentioned my beloved💔 would love to see them play blood on the clocktower again fr though especially in this werewolf format or maybe a good time society collab
    @SpookiiestbabySee it on YouTube
  • Next Halloween episode. Hide and seek in a haunted house
2 more comments
  • Gagged by sneaking in Arasha leaving SMOSH I miss her so much!!!
  • loveee Belen's interviews so much, honestly always a delight
    @mintchocotacoSee it on YouTube

Public comments from the video's page on YouTube

Add your comment

Or follow us on Telegram

The facts
Channel
Mashable
Subscribers
1,180,000
Channel views, last 7 days
784,298
Channel views, pace per day
416,147 (on a normal day: 86,792)
Video published
November 21, 2026
Video views so far
39,372 (less than a day online)
Video views, pace per day
51,883

The numbers

The Werewolf interview had already passed Mashable's usual full-day view and comment totals for a regular upload.

the video's first day
usual first day here
2,139
this video
51,883
subscribers
1,180,000
no significant change in the last 7 days
total views
492,284,012
views per day
416,147
typical day: 86,792
the video
views
39,372
likes
551
comments
30
days online
1
subscribers: this channel and similar channels
Thomas Flight
1,310,000
Mashable
1,180,000
Mista GG
1,110,000
YMS
1,070,000
Scott Adkins
1,070,000
As of November 22, 2026 · Data source: Trari Social News, Trari Traffic Trends and Ranking Platform, Google YouTube
Subscriber, view, like and comment counts are YouTube's. Rates, usual days, rankings, comparisons and categories are Trari's own calculations.
Developed with YouTube

💡 Test your knowledge

Where does Tommy Bowe joke that Smosh should read comments?