Only one Ringwraith has a name on In Deep Geek
Robert traces the Nine back to their mortal lives, including three lords of Númenórean descent.
Who were the Nazgul before they became Wraiths?
Up next
Why this story? The channel's weekly summary: what went up this week, what is drawing views now, and where the channel stands among similar channels.
The Witch-king of Angmar has a title, but Robert points out that Tolkien never gives us his personal name. That distinction is the heart of "Who were the Nazgul before they became Wraiths?", the most watched of three new In Deep Geek uploads, with about a quarter of a million views.
The one name Robert can pin down is Khamûl, the Black Easterling from Rhûn. The rest is a matter of clues: The Silmarillion identifies three of the Nine as lords of Númenórean descent, and Robert makes the case that the Witch-king was among them. He's less certain about Gothmog, the lieutenant who takes command at the Pelennor Fields. In the comments, one reader argued that the missing names suit characters who've lost their individuality, while others heard a bit of Blackadder in Sauron's cunning plans.
"The War of the Elves and Sauron" was close in total views, though the Ringwraith essay is now drawing them much faster. The older "What Did Sauron Know? (Compilation)" also remains among the channel's most active videos. The week's one trip out of Middle-earth was "Prince Baelor \"Breakspear\" Targaryen", a Westeros profile with a writing credit for History of Westeros.
In Deep Geek added about 10,000 subscribers over the week, even with its latest daily views running below normal. It was one of the stronger weeks for views among similarly sized film and TV channels: Rob Anderson had a particularly busy week, while Like Stories of Old was quieter.
Published on Trari
Where next?
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:32The Silmarillion describes how the rings gradually turned mortal men into wraiths.
- 2:00Robert argues that the Nine weren't made for men: nine remained after seven went to the dwarves.
- 4:14Khamûl, the Black Easterling from Rhûn, is the only Ringwraith Tolkien gives a personal name.
- 5:04Three were lords of Númenórean descent, and Robert thinks the Witch-king was one of them.
- 7:00Gothmog's command at the Pelennor Fields makes him a possible Ringwraith, but Tolkien doesn't settle the question.
- 9:18Robert proposes Harad, Eriador and the far north as possible homes for some of the remaining Nine.
A professional in this field? Want to write about Science & learning on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
I actually really like that the true identities of most of the Nazgûl are left a mystery for us to speculate, because not even they themselves know who they are anymore. The rings essentially made them Sauron’s puppets and stripped them of their individuality.
@lizlilac16See it on YouTubeMy favorite band, A Flock of Nazgulls.
@obfoxiousSee it on YouTubeAnd again nobody asks "how were they?"
@PiscatorLagerSee it on YouTube
4 more comments
I can't hear the term "Cunning Plan" without picturing Baldrick as Sauron 😂
@DamienJamesOFarrellSee it on YouTubeI do like the idea of Gothmog, Lieutenant of Morgul, being one of the 9.
@paulbricklerSee it on YouTubeIn my own headcanon, 3 were from the West (Black Númenóreans), 3 from the East (Rhûn), and 3 from the South (Harad).
@bigmikebeebeeSee it on YouTubeLast Time I was this Early it was still the First Age!
@DaMuss-t2tSee it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
The videos drawing views on In Deep Geek right now
- Channel
- In Deep Geek
- Subscribers
- 1,020,000 ▲ 10,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 1,387,280
- Videos published this week
- 3
- Video published
- November 20, 2026
- Video views so far
- 248,821
- Views on its first day
- 195,894
The numbers
Here's how the week's uploads, views and subscribers stack up.
💡 Test your knowledge
In which of George R.R. Martin's novellas does Baelor Breakspear take part in a trial of seven?
Baelor joins Dunk's side in the trial of seven in The Hedge Knight.





