Daniel ShenSmith questions HMRC access to private AI chats
His only upload of the week examines reported tax-record demands and the legal limits he says apply.
Why this story? The channel's weekly summary: what went up this week, what is drawing views now, and where the channel stands among similar channels.
HMRC Unacceptable Intrusion of Privacy!
Next story: Daniel ShenSmith returns with "This Cannot Be Right!"
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:55Telegraph reporting frames the discussion of HMRC seeking digital records, including taxpayers' AI conversations.
- 5:25ShenSmith argues that legal professional privilege could provide grounds to resist disclosure of some material.
- 6:24Legal advice privilege and litigation privilege protect different categories of communications and records, he explains.
- 8:12He examines the statutory restriction on demanding privileged information or documents.
- 9:21Requested information must be reasonably required to check a tax position, rather than support a fishing expedition.
Private conversations with an AI assistant are the starting point; the small print of tax law is where Daniel ShenSmith takes the discussion. His only new upload this week, "HMRC Unacceptable Intrusion of Privacy!", has passed 105,000 views.
Drawing on reporting in The Daily Telegraph, the barrister examines reports that HMRC wants to inspect taxpayers' AI chat histories when checking tax positions. He then turns to Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008, arguing that demands for digital records face limits, rather than giving the tax authority unrestricted access.
The useful distinction is between a request for relevant information and a demand for everything. ShenSmith explains legal advice privilege and litigation privilege, and suggests a taxpayer might be able to assert privilege over some material. That is a qualified argument, not a promise that every AI conversation is protected. As he puts it: "The scope must be reasonably required to check your tax position." The video also includes a sponsored VPN segment.
The new upload is comfortably the channel's busiest video for daily views. October's "This Cannot Be Right!" and September's "Do This NOW to Protect Your House!" continue to attract smaller audiences, keeping the money-and-property archive in the picture.
Across the channel, daily views are running roughly half above their usual level, while subscribers were unchanged over the week. That makes this a week of increased viewing rather than audience expansion, with the fresh HMRC discussion providing its clearest focus.
His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs is the UK government department responsible for collecting taxes and administering some forms of state support and other regulatory systems.
More on Wikipedia ›A British conservative daily broadsheet newspaper published by Telegraph Media Group and distributed in the UK and internationally.
More on Wikipedia ›Published on Trari
Where next?
What do you think?
Want to know when somebody answers you?
The videos drawing views on Daniel ShenSmith right now
- Channel
- Daniel ShenSmith
- Subscribers
- 107,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 108,058
- Videos published this week
- 1
- Video published
- November 11, 2026
- Video views so far
- 105,382
- Views on its first day
- 87,764
The numbers
Here is the week's viewing and subscriber picture for Daniel ShenSmith.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which newspaper's reporting does ShenSmith discuss in this video?
ShenSmith introduces Telegraph reporting about HMRC's proposed access to digital records.



