Finebaum floats AI referees after BYU-Notre Dame clock controversy
ESPN College Football's fast-starting reaction clip moves from Notre Dame's playoff predicament to a half-joking technological fix for officiating.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 112,473 views a day, 11 times a normal first day on this channel (10,386).
Finebaum’s BYU vs. Notre Dame reaction
Paul Finebaum gives the Big 12 credit before giving college football's officiating a much harsher review. The conference, he says, at least offered transparency over the clock controversy surrounding BYU's win against Notre Dame.
Then comes his proposed replacement for the humans: "Just let AI officiate the games."
It is a half-joking finish to a discussion that begins with serious consequences for Notre Dame's playoff hopes. ESPN College Football's "Finebaum's BYU vs. Notre Dame reaction" drew about 65,000 views in ten hours, already well beyond the channel's usual full-day audience for a Short.
The host raises the disputed seconds and argues that clock mistakes need fixing. Finebaum broadens the criticism beyond that finish, and beyond college football, to include the NFL. "I've never seen a worse year for officiating," he says.
Viewers are not simply debating whether another second belonged on the clock. Several point to other calls they believe were missed against both teams; others question how precisely the clock started on the final play. A recurring argument is that the ending should not be judged separately from everything that preceded it.
ESPN's separate "BYU takes down Notre Dame" Short also drew an unusually large early audience. For a longer treatment, Greg McElroy's Week 7 takeaways devotes a chapter to his argument that BYU took away Notre Dame's margin for error.
Published on Trari
Where next?
What viewers say
BYU had a touchdown called back on a very controversial call, one second or one bad call is not the deciding factor. It all equaled out. Either team could have won, it was a great game. I’m a BYU fan but I would have accepted either way.
@Msp-o5wSee it on YouTubeA second is debatable as the clock is not exact when started when it’s hiked so a second is marginal and unless we have a non person entity starting and stopping clock precisely we can’t complain about the second at the end.
@winstonsmith5211See it on YouTubeThe refs were not the reason for the score, missed throws, fumble, bad play calls, poor preparation were reasons.
@mattpatrick2564See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
- Channel
- ESPN College Football
- Subscribers
- 1,420,000 ▲ 10,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 22,120,099
- Channel views, pace per day
- 2,544,426 (on a normal day: 4,138,065)
- Video published
- October 18, 2026
- Video views so far
- 64,860 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 112,473
The numbers
Finebaum's reaction has already surpassed ESPN College Football's usual first-day views for a Short. The separate BYU victory clip is also running ahead of its usual pace.
💡 Test your knowledge
What is the nickname of BYU's sports teams?
Brigham Young University's teams are known as the Cougars.



