News 229K views since yesterday

Zelenskyy says US floated Donbas-for-NATO exchange

DW News examines the reported proposal, with analyst Michael Kimmage calling it "science fiction" and pointing to obstacles within NATO and Moscow's demands.

Channel:

DW News Story of November 15, 2026Trari Newsroom

Why this story? One of DW News's most watched videos since yesterday, with 229,145 views.

Ukraine says US floated trading Donbas for NATO membership | DW News

What did you think?

Things we can learn from the video

Press to jump

0:00DW reports Zelenskyy's statement that US envoys floated exchanging Donbas for Ukrainian NATO membership.
2:34Nick Connolly describes Moscow's wider NATO demands and contrasts them with limited progress on humanitarian agreements.
5:51Michael Kimmage calls the proposal "science fiction," citing NATO consensus problems and Russia's demands.
7:22Kimmage suggests bilateral defense-industrial partnerships could bolster Ukraine without providing a formal security guarantee.
8:26Kimmage argues that today's distribution of power makes a Yalta-style division between major powers impossible.

Ukraine would hand over Donbas to Russia in exchange for NATO membership: that is the idea President Volodymyr Zelenskyy says US envoys raised, according to DW News. The report describes a proposal floated in talks, not an agreed settlement.

DW shows Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner meeting Zelenskyy in Dublin after talks with Vladimir Putin in Moscow. The anchor relays Zelenskyy's response that he would ask Ukrainian society whether to accept such an arrangement.

From Kyiv, DW correspondent Nick Connolly interprets that response as reluctance to take personal responsibility for the proposed exchange. He also describes a fundamental obstacle on the Russian side: Moscow's demands extend beyond Ukrainian territory to rolling back NATO's expansion. Limited humanitarian agreements, including prisoner swaps, have not resolved those wider differences, he explains.

Michael Kimmage, introduced as director of the Kennan Institute, is more categorical about the proposal's prospects. He calls it "science fiction," citing the absence of NATO consensus and Russian demands to dismantle the alliance's post-1997 arrangements.

Asked what protection Ukraine could realistically obtain, Kimmage points instead to deeper bilateral defense-industrial partnerships. These could strengthen Ukraine's ability to defend itself, he argues, but would not amount to a formal security guarantee.

The discussion closes by examining the planned meeting between Putin, Donald Trump and Xi Jinping. Kimmage rejects a simple comparison with the great-power bargaining at Yalta in 1945, arguing that Washington and Moscow no longer command the same power to divide the world between them.

Published on Trari

Most watched today ›