Dude Perfect's pirate Overtime sends Sparky to Pittsburgh in costume
With Tyler Toney sitting this one out, the episode moves the desk onto San Diego's San Salvador and adds a Jack Sparrow-styled magician, a cannon and a staged sword fight.
Why this story? One of the most watched videos since yesterday, with 1,186,795 views.
Overtime 52: PIRATE EDITION
Video summary
Press to jump
- 0:00Aboard a sailing ship, the crew announces Tyler is absent and hands Sparky the desk.
- 2:13Coby introduces "Jock Sparrow," a Jack Sparrow impersonator who performs close-up magic.
- 6:24Cory fires a blank from a replica pirate deck cannon over the ocean.
- 7:53A staged fight scene: Sparky's prisoner uprising against Cody's Captain Jones.
- 15:13Sparky ranks fictional and commercial pirates in the Top 10, revealing his number one at 19:15.
- 21:52Wheel Unfortunate picks Sparky's punishment, which takes him to Pittsburgh from 23:18.
Tyler Toney is the one Dude Perfect member missing from "Overtime 52: PIRATE EDITION," and the episode says so within seconds. "He said, 'Sparky, the desk is yours,'" Sparky tells the crew. He takes the middle seat for an episode filmed on the deck of the San Salvador, the sailing ship at the Maritime Museum of San Diego.
The episode has drawn about 1.2 million views in its first 14 hours. Overtime is presented by State Farm, and the show says so on screen.
Cool Not Cool gets the full nautical treatment. Garrett offers a wind-up mini boat motor that works as a coffee stirrer. Coby brings out "Jock Sparrow," a Jack Sparrow impersonator who turns out to be a close-up magician, complete with sponge balls and linking rings. Sparky's treasure chest holds an autographed Paul Skenes rookie patch card. Cody teases a resort trip before producing an antique pirate sword. Cory tops them all with a replica deck cannon. "I've never seen a cannon fired on a real pirate ship," he says, and fires a blank out over the ocean.
The centerpiece is a staged, cinematic fight scene filmed with the cast of Pirate's Dinner Adventure. Sparky plays a prisoner leading an uprising against Captain Jones, played by Cody. Midway through, Sparky concedes, "Technically, this should be Ty."
That thought runs through the comments too. The most liked ones dwell on how strange Overtime feels without Ty, and on how fully Sparky filled the middle seat. A magic-themed episode is a popular request, and a few viewers want Cody to get a turn at the Top 10.
Sparky's own Top 10 ranks fictional and commercial pirates. He fends off Jock Sparrow's attempt to claim first place and puts Long John Silver's at number one. Cody calls the list "atrocious."
Then Wheel Unfortunate lands on Sparky: dress as a pirate at a Pirates game. He flies to Pittsburgh in full costume, where an airport agent tells him he is the first pirate she has seen in 40 years. PNC Park turns out to be closed, because the baseball season is over. The replacement punishment brings the Top 10 back around: 100 Long John Silver's hush puppies, eaten outside the ballpark over several hours.
Published on Trari
Where next?
What viewers say
The way they slowly brought sparky into becoming a regular part of the crew is master class
@ryanb87zSee it on YouTubeAbsolutely need a magic theme OT
@mhaj58See it on YouTubeActually doing this on a ship is hard-core commitment to the theme of this video.
@teddymassey-f8zSee it on YouTube
5 more comments
For Sparky's performance in top ten he must walk the plank.
@poutubeofficialSee it on YouTubeIt feels so weird with sparky as middle man and not ty😭
@SomehowFrostSee it on YouTubeIf they did a top 10 worst top 10s, this would be number 1
@michaelhilvert6425See it on YouTubeA new Overtime? My day just got even better
@RoboWhisperer-78See it on YouTubeWasn’t expecting a new OT or an OT like this
@Romanator518See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
- Channel
- Dude Perfect
- Subscribers
- 62,800,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 41,854,152
- Channel views, pace per day
- 3,795,538 (on a normal day: 5,976,708)
- Video published
- October 24, 2026
- Video views so far
- 1,186,795 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 1,553,591
The numbers
The pirate episode passed a million views in its first 14 hours, with thousands of comments already under it.
💡 Test your knowledge
Long John Silver, namesake of Sparky's number-one pick, first appeared in which novel?
Robert Louis Stevenson created the one-legged pirate Long John Silver for Treasure Island, published as a book in 1883.

