West Point professor says climate-science refusal cost him his job
Democracy Watch's excerpt from The Damage Report examines Adam Kalkstein's lawsuit and the argument that climate education matters to military readiness.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 204,496 views a day, 13 times a normal first day on this channel (16,040).
Hegseth Disaster BLOWS UP As West Point Professor Refuses Alarming Order
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:22Iadarola introduces Kalkstein's account of being ordered to remove climate science from his teaching.
- 0:48New York Times reporting describes the disputed meeting and Kalkstein's contract non-renewal months later.
- 1:12Kalkstein's lawsuit invokes First Amendment rights; his lawyer argues climate knowledge is necessary for military readiness.
- 4:46The hosts contrast conservative free-speech arguments with the teaching restrictions described in the case.
Adam Kalkstein refused to remove human contributions to climate change from his teaching at West Point. The geography professor says his contract was subsequently not renewed, and he is suing the academy over his First Amendment rights.
That account anchors a discussion by John Iadarola and Brett Erlich on TYT's The Damage Report, shared by the clips channel Democracy Watch. The upload reached roughly 125,000 views in ten hours, a much faster start than the channel's usual regular videos.
Drawing on New York Times reporting, Iadarola recounts Kalkstein's meeting with academy leadership: the instruction to change his teaching, his objection that doing so would be immoral and possibly illegal, and his refusal to resign. The contract non-renewal followed months later, according to the account presented in the segment.
The discussion's central argument goes beyond academic freedom. Iadarola points to climate disruption as a national-security concern, while Kalkstein's lawyer argues that military readiness requires understanding climate science. West Point educates future Army officers, making the question one of what they need to learn before taking command.
Erlich then turns to criticism of Pete Hegseth's approach to defense leadership. The closing exchange contrasts conservative arguments about free speech with the restrictions on teaching described in Kalkstein's case.
The United States Military Academy in New York, which trains cadets to become commissioned officers in the U.S. Army.
More on Wikipedia ›An American political commentator and YouTube personality who hosts The Young Turks and The Damage Report.
More on Wikipedia ›An American political comedian and executive producer at The Young Turks network, where he also hosts Happy Half Hour.
More on Wikipedia ›The U.S. secretary of defense since 2025, an Army veteran and former television personality.
More on Wikipedia ›Published on Trari
Where next?
- Channel
- Democracy Watch
- Subscribers
- 156,000 ▲ 2,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 2,215,006
- Channel views, pace per day
- 330,521 (on a normal day: 292,775)
- Video published
- November 9, 2026
- Video views so far
- 124,865 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 204,496
The numbers
The West Point discussion drew an unusually fast start for Democracy Watch, well before its first full day online.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which constitutional amendment does Kalkstein's lawsuit invoke in the segment?
Iadarola describes the lawsuit as alleging violations of Kalkstein's First Amendment rights.


