A Yalta comparison for the Shenzhen summit
As Trump pressed for nuclear arms talks, a French broadcast asked what it meant for Ukraine and Europe to be outside the room.
La rencontre historique entre Donald Trump, Vladimir Poutine et Xi Jinping
Up next
Why this story? One of BFMTV's most watched videos since yesterday, with 69,935 views.
BFMTV: The French 24-hour news channel, on air since 2005, owned by the Saadé family's CMA CGM group. 2.7M subscribers and 2B views.
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:00Xi, Putin and Trump pose for the official photograph before taking their seats at a round table.
- 2:37Putin argues that the three countries share responsibility for international peace and security.
- 6:48Trump calls for curbing nuclear proliferation, citing Iran, and mentions the war in Ukraine.
- 22:13Patrick Sauce invokes Yalta to describe the risk of major powers making decisions without Europe at the table.
- 27:45From Kyiv, Cyrille Amoursky reports that Ukrainians are reacting cautiously to talks held without them.
- 46:36Xi calls for cooperation among major powers and urges them to prevent a nuclear war.
Patrick Sauce reached for a comparison from the closing months of World War II as Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping met in Shenzhen: Yalta. The international editor at France's BFMTV wasn't reporting a deal to divide up territory. He was warning that the three powers could make decisions about Europe's security without European governments at the table.
The broadcast, titled "La rencontre historique entre Donald Trump, Vladimir Poutine et Xi Jinping" ("The historic meeting between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping"), follows the three presidents from an official photograph to a round table. Putin invokes their countries' wartime role and their responsibilities as permanent members of the UN Security Council. Trump thanks Xi for hosting, argues that countries should keep talking even when they disagree, and singles out Iran as he makes the case against nuclear proliferation. In remarks aired later in the programme, Xi calls for cooperation among major powers and urges them to prevent a nuclear war.
Defence commentator Didier François reads Trump's opening as an effort to enlist Putin's help in bringing China into arms reduction talks. He describes Xi as more guarded and focused on Taiwan. U.S. affairs commentator Stéphan Bureau argues that Trump is using the summit to recast a difficult situation in Iran as a case for disarmament and non-proliferation. The panel also considers how competition over advanced chips shapes the relationship between Washington and Beijing.
The coverage cuts to Kyiv, where correspondent Cyrille Amoursky reports a cautious reaction among Ukrainians to talks being held without them. Trump mentions Ukraine in his opening remarks, but the broadcast offers no account of what the leaders settled behind closed doors. That distinction is at the heart of Sauce's comparison: being mentioned at the table is not the same as having a seat there.
Published on Trari
Where next?
What do you think?
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- BFMTV
- Subscribers
- 2,720,000 ▲ 10,000 this week
- Video published
- November 19, 2026
- Video views so far
- 69,935 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 78,755
The numbers
The broadcast drew about 70,000 views since yesterday, making it the second most watched new upload from France's leading news channels over that period.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which river runs through Kyiv?
Kyiv lies on both banks of the Dnipro River.


