TLDR News EU puts Shenzhen's Yalta analogy to the test
Jack Kelly uses an economic comparison with Italy to explain why he doesn't put Russia in the same category as the US and China.
No, Russia is Not a Superpower
Up next
Why this story? One of the most watched videos since yesterday, with 390,840 views.
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:00Kelly opens with the Shenzhen meeting and asks whether it makes sense to compare it with Yalta.
- 1:17IMF estimates show the economic scale of the US and China, both at market exchange rates and adjusted for purchasing power.
- 2:18Kelly contrasts China's strength in manufacturing with America's influence over global finance.
- 4:00Russia's economy is roughly the size of Italy's in nominal terms, and its share of global manufacturing is much smaller.
- 5:21Kelly cites setbacks in Ukraine and declining influence among former Soviet states as limits on Russia's reach.
- 6:03Kelly argues that Putin's projection of strength and assumptions left over from the Cold War help explain Russia's standing.
Vladimir Putin had a seat alongside Donald Trump and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. On TLDR News EU, Jack Kelly asks what that seat says about Russia's power. The comparison with Yalta, where the leaders of the US, Britain and the Soviet Union met in 1945, gives him a starting point. His answer is in the title: "No, Russia is Not a Superpower".
The explainer drew about 391,000 views in 18 hours. Rather than recap the talks, Kelly lays out what he thinks a superpower needs. China's case rests in part on the scale of its manufacturing. America's rests on the dollar's place in global finance as well as its military reach, technology and cultural influence. When Kelly gets to Russia, the country he puts beside it on the chart is Italy: their economies are roughly the same size in nominal terms.
Kelly also points to Russia's military setbacks in Ukraine and what he describes as its waning influence among former Soviet states. Viewers kept coming back to another measure of power: how much weight Russia's nuclear arsenal should carry in that assessment.
Kelly's explanation for why Putin still gets treated as a peer of Trump and Xi is partly about Putin's own projection of strength and partly about how long Cold War assumptions have stuck around. "Russia is not the Soviet Union, and this week's trilateral is not Yalta," he says before the video turns to a sponsored segment for Proton Mail.
Xi is China's president and the general secretary of the Chinese Communist Party.
More on Wikipedia ›Published on Trari
Where next?
What do you think?
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- TLDR News EU
- Subscribers
- 1,150,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 2,327,300
- Video published
- November 19, 2026
- Video views so far
- 390,840 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 440,990
The numbers
The first 18 hours brought in more than twice as many comments as a regular TLDR News EU video usually gets in a full day.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which British prime minister attended the Yalta Conference?
Churchill represented Britain at Yalta alongside Franklin D. Roosevelt for the US and Joseph Stalin for the Soviet Union.


