Pattinson's Bond gets a nine from The Telegraph's Robbie Collin
The critic assembles his ideal 007 from earlier performances, while viewers spot a Pierce Brosnan-shaped gap.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 116,198 views a day, 11 times a normal first day on this channel (10,253).
Robert Pattinson is Bond: Film critic reacts to new 007 casting
Next story: Netanyahu and Likud seek Shin Bet inquiry into Arab vote
Sean Connery's physical menace, George Lazenby's vulnerability and Roger Moore's unruffled humour: Robbie Collin has a fairly exacting list of requirements for James Bond. Robert Pattinson, he concludes, looks well equipped for the assignment.
In The Telegraph's Short, "Robert Pattinson is Bond: Film critic reacts to new 007 casting", Collin works through the qualities he wants the newly cast actor to bring to the role. Timothy Dalton supplies severity and the sense of a working agent; Daniel Craig adds physical and emotional brutality.
It is a miniature tour through Bond history, from Connery in Dr. No to Moore's submarine car in The Spy Who Loved Me. But several viewers have the same question: where is Pierce Brosnan? Comments single out his suave presence and GoldenEye, with one viewer remembering him as the Bond they grew up with.
Collin's verdict on Pattinson also has a business dimension. He considers the actor's Batman credentials and the commercial risk calculations behind Amazon's choice, calling him "a wild choice, but also I think a smart one." His overall rating is nine out of ten.
The Short drew roughly 75,000 views in less than half a day, an unusually fast start for The Telegraph's short-form uploads. A companion video, "Robert Pattinson the most mainstream James Bond to date", is also drawing an above-usual audience, extending the paper's argument that an established blockbuster star makes commercial sense for 007.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Film & TV on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
Wow no brosnan mention? He embodied what bond should be in my opinion.
@CipherkaiiSee it on YouTubeI think this is a great pick. Pattinson is a brilliant actor. I think he'll nail the mixture of swagger and brutality.
@PotterbaseSee it on YouTubeDalton brought a gritier portrayal of Bond. Pity the world was not ready for his version back then.
@goodrealmSee it on YouTube
3 more comments
Pierce Brosnan was Bond I grew up with, he was superb, he had the suave, swag and looks
@venvedamSee it on YouTubePattinson, will offer a mystique edge, he’ll be great. All bonds don’t need to be the same
@pauljames6721See it on YouTubeHe'll do it his way, mature into the role as per previous Bonds with each film... new Bond. Congratulations 🎊 Robert Pattinson and good luck! 🍾🍸🇬🇧
@dionnegonsalves8188See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- The Telegraph
- Subscribers
- 6,210,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 4,568,877
- Channel views, pace per day
- 317,753 (on a normal day: 718,030)
- Video published
- November 16, 2026
- Video views so far
- 75,221 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 116,198
The numbers
Both Pattinson Shorts are running ahead of The Telegraph's usual short-form start. The critic's assessment has drawn the larger audience so far.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which car becomes a submarine in The Spy Who Loved Me?
Roger Moore's Bond drives a white Lotus Esprit that transforms into a submarine.


