Hartcher sees risks for Ukraine and Taiwan in Trump's three-way talks
On The Morning Edition, the international editor argues that Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin stand to gain from the meeting even if it produces no deal.
Trump, Xi and Putin: How much damage could one meeting do?
Up next
Why this story? A video put up today and watched far beyond the channel's usual.
24 more stories on Trump–Xi–Putin trilateral meeting ›
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:18Selinger-Morris invokes Yalta to explain fears that the leaders might carve out spheres of influence.
- 5:35Hartcher doubts that nuclear arms talks or efforts to end the Iran conflict will win meaningful concessions.
- 8:23Hartcher reads Trump's refusal to address Nvidia chip export controls as an attempt to placate Beijing.
- 11:35Hartcher singles out Ukraine and Taiwan as particularly vulnerable to decisions made at the summit.
- 12:17Hartcher says hosting the meeting bolsters Xi's standing and gives Putin a way out of diplomatic isolation.
- 17:00Hartcher sees Trump's approach as inconsistent with the Quad's joint statement opposing coercion.
The people Peter Hartcher is most worried about won't be at the table. On The Morning Edition, the international and political editor tells Samantha Selinger-Morris why the planned meeting between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in China leaves Ukraine and Taiwan particularly exposed.
Selinger-Morris opens with footage of the 1945 Yalta Conference to frame a question: could three powerful leaders make decisions about other places without them in the room? Hartcher points to Trump's past description of Taiwan as a bargaining chip. He's also sceptical that Trump's stated agenda, which includes nuclear arms limits and an end to the conflict with Iran, will yield meaningful concessions from Beijing or Moscow.
The episode drew about 5,100 views in under three hours on The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, nearly twice what a comparable upload usually draws in a full first day.
For Hartcher, the meeting itself is already a diplomatic gain for Putin, whom it brings out of isolation, and for Xi, who gets to convene the other two leaders. From Australia's perspective, Hartcher sees a tension closer to home: Trump joined Australia, India and Japan in a Quad statement opposing coercion, but Hartcher doesn't think that pledge offers much reassurance given how Trump is approaching the meeting.
Published on Trari
Where next?
What do you think?
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Subscribers
- 271,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 529,832
- Channel views, pace per day
- 49,706 (on a normal day: 84,872)
- Video published
- November 19, 2026
The numbers
The episode had already passed the channel's usual full first-day view count for a video of this length.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which of these countries is a member of the Quad alongside Australia, India and the United States?
Japan is one of the four members of the Quad, formally known as the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue.


