Josh plays the murderer at the Sidemen's country-house dinner
Tobi hosts as lord of the manor, and 13 guests, from Jme to true crime creator Eleanor Neale, are sent to mingle without knowing who wants them dead.
No. 16 on the daily chartNo. 5 on the Comedy chart
Why this story? One of the most watched videos since yesterday, with 1,563,307 views.
SIDEMEN MURDER MYSTERY DINNER
Next story: Faith gets repeat invitations from Sidemen's pub-quiz viewers
Video summary
Press to jump
- 0:00A police car arrives at the mansion after a radio report of fatalities, then the story rewinds 24 hours.
- 0:45Tobi explains that he has invited 13 YouTubers and will hand out secret roles.
- 2:14Josh is named a murderer and told to kill someone before dinner.
- 5:23Bach becomes a murderer with a specific task: lure a victim into the oak bedroom's bathtub.
- 12:16Tobi gathers everyone on the grand staircase to announce the rules.
- 14:45Ethan rides a motorised stairlift with drinks, and guests find a doll whose head pops off.
Bach has to get somebody into a bathtub before dinner. At most country-house gatherings that would be an awkward request. In "SIDEMEN MURDER MYSTERY DINNER", it is his first assignment as a secret killer.
The video opens like a television whodunit: a police radio reports several dead content creators at a mansion, a squad car pulls up, and the story jumps back 24 hours. On screen it carries its own title, "The Motive: A Sidemen Murder Mystery". Tobi Brown plays lord of the manor, greeting each guest at the door and quietly telling them which side they are on.
The viewer is let in on the secret early. Josh is made a murderer within the first few minutes and told plainly: "You must murder someone before dinner." Bach gets the bathtub brief, and Cole Anderson-James later learns that the other two are his partners. Everyone else, including Ethan, Harry, Simon, Jme, JackSucksAtLife, Arthur Hill and Zac Alsop, arrives believing the house is mostly harmless. Eleanor Neale, a true crime creator by trade, is among the innocents.
The mansion supplies its own distractions. Ethan discovers a motorised stairlift and rides it with drinks in hand, a doll's head pops off, and Bach tries to make the bathtub more inviting by climbing in himself. Nobody joins him.
It comes two weeks after the group raced to escape a different mansion, and it has started faster. Nine hours after going up it had passed 1.5 million views, and the comments were already more than twice what the channel's long videos usually collect in a whole first day.
Much of that talk is about Josh. Viewers compare his calm here with his record of getting caught in the group's Among Us games, point to how long he held certain people's trust, and keep asking for a second murder mystery.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Comedy & challenges on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
they casually dropped the best sidemen sunday of all time
@prithvivt4888See it on YouTubeima be honest, we NEED another murder mystery
@luvtatoSee it on YouTubeYou know your a good murderer when you got Simon to vote you as the most trustworthy person
@crowkid5553See it on YouTube
7 more comments
i think 10 simon among us masterclasses can't equal what josh did in this video.
@hamzawazir6763See it on YouTubeCasually dropped a Netflix level of “whodunit”
@Tejasw-2332See it on YouTubeEthan did what he does best: Being a confident Innocent, but also completely wrong about everything, just like in Among Us
@NeumannKlausSee it on YouTubeProps to Tobi and Vik for theorizing a BANGER of a Sidemen Sunday.
@shriramkumbhojkar4515See it on YouTubeJosh playing a blinder here then stinking up the next sidemen among us is gonna be such a funny contrast😭
@gold_287See it on YouTubeyour telling me that josh can pull of this masterclass but not hop in a vent after getting a kill in among us
@etanator00See it on YouTubeAnyone else thought this was the sidemen’s best video this year??
@thiyanagi1859See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
A question for readersWhich guest would you have suspected first at the Sidemen's murder mystery dinner?
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- Sidemen
- Subscribers
- 23,400,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 11,450,418
- Channel views, pace per day
- 1,832,618 (on a normal day: 1,452,112)
- Video published
- November 15, 2026
- Video views so far
- 1,563,307 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 2,835,390
The numbers
A Sunday upload that drew more than 1.5 million views in its first nine hours, with a comment section far busier than usual.
💡 Test your knowledge
What title does Tobi take as host of the Sidemen's murder mystery?
The video's on-screen tag introduces him as "tobi, lord of the manor".


