John Robbie makes the case for the deepest Springboks squad, not the greatest team
The former Ireland international's RTÉ Sport appearance drew about 69,000 views in 18 hours, and some listeners remembered him from South African radio.
Was Rassie Right? | South Africa, Refs & Controversy | HOWLER RUGBY
Up next
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 78,651 views a day, 26 times a normal first day on this channel (3,028).
One more story on Ireland–South Africa rugby match ›
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:49Robbie credits Erasmus's popularity across South Africa to back-to-back World Cup wins and his work developing players.
- 3:20Robbie argues that video reviews of minor infringements make rugby less entertaining.
- 5:07Robbie says the Springboks brought a referee into camp full-time to improve discipline and learn the laws.
- 10:46Gavin Cumiskey asks whether Erasmus courts controversy as a distraction, but Robbie puts it down to passion and knowledge.
- 13:58Robbie favours the 1937 Springboks as a team but calls Erasmus's squad the deepest South Africa has had.
- 17:15Robbie explains why he regrets touring apartheid South Africa with Ireland and urges athletes to learn the history behind protests.
John Robbie spent part of his birthday on Howler Rugby, calling in from South Africa before the Springboks' match against Ireland. He had a distinction he wanted to make about Rassie Erasmus's side: "It's not the greatest Springbok team, it's the greatest Springbok squad." For the greatest team, Robbie went back to 1937. What sets this group apart for him is how much talent it has beyond the starting line-up.
The interview was recorded before news broke of Erasmus's six-match suspension, RTÉ Sport says. Asked whether the coach uses public controversy to take the spotlight off his players, Robbie argued that Erasmus speaks out because he knows the laws and cares about how they're applied. Robbie had his own complaint about officiating: he thinks video reviews of minor infringements are making rugby less entertaining.
The comment section drew more than a hundred times as many comments in 18 hours as a regular RTÉ Sport upload usually gets in a full day. Amid the talk about referees, some listeners had a different subject: they remembered hearing Robbie on South Africa's Radio 702, and wanted him back on the panel.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Sports on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
John Robbie. My old man introduced me to you back in the old 702 days! You've always been highly respected in SA for being unbais and blatantly factual! L8ve your passion !!!
@Aurora..BorealisSee it on YouTubeMake John Robbie a regular! 🇮🇪🇿🇦
@marcómaicínSee it on YouTubeThank you John, brilliant...still miss you on 702!!!
@LennieGovenderSee it on YouTube
1 more comment
Have ALWAYS loved John Robbie here in SA. Many many years ago he was our best pundit on TV...
@KwizatsHaderach8See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- RTÉ Sport
- Subscribers
- 126,000
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 684,055
- Channel views, pace per day
- 393,620 (on a normal day: 54,232)
- Video published
- November 18, 2026
- Video views so far
- 69,087 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 78,651
The numbers
The Robbie interview was already well past a typical first day before it was a day old. Views across RTÉ Sport were also running at more than seven times the channel's usual daily pace.
💡 Test your knowledge
What does TMO stand for in rugby union?
The Television Match Official uses video replays to help the on-field officials review incidents.


