Polygon's Shelf Quest becomes a McElroy family memory tour
Justin and Griffin browse Videogamesnewyork, revisiting a regretted Virtual Boy purchase and a disputed gold Zelda cartridge swap.
Why this story? The channel's weekly summary: what went up this week, what is drawing views now, and where the channel stands among similar channels.
Betrayal! Not Clickbait! Ocarina of Time almost tore the McElroy Brothers apart | Shelf Quest
Next story: Vice City's neon courts come to NBA 2K27
Video summary
Press to jump
- 1:16A Virtual Boy display brings back Griffin's memory of an expensive childhood purchase he immediately regretted.
- 2:23NES browsing leads to Zelda opinions and Justin's story about an Easter gift hidden in pants.
- 6:50Griffin recalls a gold Ocarina of Time cartridge swap; Justin disputes remembering the incident.
- 8:03Griffin examines customized Nintendo DS Lite systems and Japanese 3DS faceplates.
- 9:05Justin revisits his criticism of Heavy Rain and writer David Cage.
- 12:30The brothers find The Biggest Loser games and demonstrate Boom Blox's throwing motions for the camera.
The shelves unlock everything. A Virtual Boy behind glass sends Griffin McElroy back to a childhood purchase he regretted enough to cry over, while NES cartridges prompt Justin's memory of finding Zelda II hidden in a pair of pants at Easter.
Polygon's most-watched new upload brings its two founders back for Shelf Quest, with roughly 257,000 views. Justin and Griffin, also familiar as the character-creation duo behind Monster Factory, turn the store visit into a mix of hardware inspection, old opinions and brotherly cross-examination. Griffin remembers Justin swapping his gold Ocarina of Time cartridge for a gray copy. Justin says he doesn't remember it happening.
For longtime viewers, the reunion itself is part of the attraction. Comments keep returning to the pleasing oddity of Justin and Griffin introducing themselves on a Polygon video, alongside memories of Griffin's Amiibo Corner. The separate cartridge-story upload currently has the channel's busiest daily viewing, with the full episode also carrying substantial momentum.
Five uploads made up the week. Elsewhere, Patches and Simone welcomed Oli Welsh to Point It Out! to examine World of Warcraft Forever's appeal. The fresh game-direction feature takes a different route behind the scenes, asking directors and producers about difficult decisions, small-team development and the making of Denshattack!'s soundtrack. It is already among Polygon's busiest videos right now, giving a week rich in gaming memories something newly made to investigate too.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Gaming on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
Justin and Griffin in a POLYGON VIDEO? What is this, 2016???
@JS-uo6rhSee it on YouTubeJustin and Griffin McElroy having to say who they are and plug their platforms on a Polygon video is so insanely funny
@ZoeyHughes-q8cSee it on YouTubeLol Justin just wandering off during the Zelda cartridge story
@BrittleBonesBrigadeSee it on YouTube
4 more comments
I think my favourite McElroy sub-genre is Justin trying desperately to "preserve Griffin's brand."
@bunnies.islandSee it on YouTubeUnfortunate that Griffin stopped Amiibo Corner before the massive Guardian Amiibo from Breath of the Wild came out.
@angerpanda1See it on YouTubeFor some reason I was expecting Griffin's tag to be "Youngest Brother 30 Under 30 Media Luminary"
@100deadSee it on YouTubeRemembering Griffin shoving amiibos in his mouth took me back like that Ratatouille meme 🤣
@Del129See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
The videos drawing views on Polygon right now
Someone stole Griffin's gold Ocarina of Time?!41,219 views · 2026-11-16
Griffin and Justin McElroy are coming to Shelf Quest30,622 views · 2026-11-12
Why is everyone obsessed with World of Warcraft again? | Point It Out!23,030 views · 2026-11-12
Making an extraordinary video game: The BEST game direction of 20268,283 views · 2026-11-16
- Channel
- Polygon
- Subscribers
- 1,400,000
- Videos published this week
- 5
- Video published
- November 12, 2026
- Video views so far
- 256,798
The numbers
Here is how Polygon's uploads and audience figures look this week.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which podcast do Justin, Travis and Griffin McElroy host together?
The three McElroy brothers host the comedy advice podcast My Brother, My Brother and Me.

