LaurenZside's "i stopped trying..." argues for less-polished thumbnails
Her video essay shows simpler images winning her thumbnail tests, while viewers explain why they avoid the glossy alternatives.
No. 98 on the daily chartNo. 8 on the Tech chart
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 815,585 views a day, 4 times a normal first day on this channel (202,143).
i stopped trying...
Next story: LaurenZside reopens Hotdog House in a costume to match
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:00Lauren explains that her less-polished thumbnails and titles are a deliberate change.
- 5:43She examines how thumbnail-testing practices helped spread similar expressions and high-contrast colors.
- 13:25Her thumbnail tests show screenshots and simple expressions outperforming heavily edited alternatives.
- 16:37She proposes that viewers have learned to tune out images that look too optimized.
- 20:00Her second theory links AI oversaturation with distrust of polished thumbnails, including human-made edits.
- 22:50Her third theory is that viewers miss watching people have genuine fun rather than retention-focused productions.
LaurenZside has deliberately made her thumbnails look less polished. Not because she's giving up, as the title "i stopped trying..." led some viewers to fear, but because she says the simpler versions keep working better.
In what she describes as only her second scripted, researched video essay, the gaming comedian turns her attention from playing games to the business of getting people to click on them. She traces a familiar visual language: heightened expressions, high-contrast colors and carefully engineered images that begin to resemble one another.
Her central question is straightforward: "What happens when everything looks optimized? How do you stand out?"
The most concrete answer comes when Lauren opens her own thumbnail tests. She presents examples in which plain screenshots and simple expressions outperform heavily edited alternatives on click-through rate and share of watch time. Those results underpin her decision to spend less energy perfecting the packaging, rather than less energy making videos she enjoys.
Lauren offers several possible explanations. Viewers may have learned to tune out highly designed thumbnails. Widespread AI imagery may also make polished human edits look suspicious. Or, as she puts it, "Maybe people just miss watching people." Shayne Topp's simply titled "Books." becomes one example of the casual, personal approach she means.
The essay itself has drawn roughly 579,000 views in thirteen hours, with its estimated first-day audience running at four times her usual level. The comments are already nearly three times her usual full-day total.
Beyond the initial alarm about the title, viewers describe deliberately skipping overproduced thumbnails and wanting more room for gameplay, unforced reactions and slower moments. Lauren's own conclusion is to keep the playful intros and videos she loves, without trying to optimize every detail.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Tech on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
Proving your point… I intentionally stay away from over-produced thumbnails. I’m intentionally trying to train my brain away from the “Oo shiny!!” mentality. I try and look for less YouTube short-type content. I love that you’re doing this!!
@amfishSee it on YouTubeThe title made me think this was a depressing video😢😢💔
@0nlyV1a67See it on YouTube> "This video doesn't even matter!"
Yes it does. I love hearing what people are passionate about and learning from them. I also think you're really onto something. I don't want big adrenaline hits from youtube, i want to have some kind of human connection, especially with reaction type content. So the thumbnails that look more human - flaws and all - definitely draw me in more.@fireink192See it on YouTube
3 more comments
I always think that AI or thumbnails that don’t look real are gonna be a video more boring than it might actually be.
@Res.watchesSee it on YouTube11:37 “it’s true she loves to yap” 😭 i love when editor Emily contributes commentary to the video it’s always so funny
@Rainy_jay8876See it on YouTube4:02 lowkey i miss that era of yt everything was so low cortisol
@jenniffaaaSee it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- LaurenZside
- Subscribers
- 10,500,000 ▲ 100,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 7,395,327
- Channel views, pace per day
- 1,679,040 (on a normal day: 908,804)
- Video published
- November 15, 2026
- Video views so far
- 578,587 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 815,585
The numbers
The essay is reaching viewers much faster than LaurenZside's usual regular upload, with an especially busy comment section before its first full day is over.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which simply titled Shayne Topp video does Lauren use as an example?
Lauren highlights Shayne Topp's "Books." as an example of minimalist, personal creator content.


