Jimmy Carr turns a joke-writing question into a lesson in paying attention
The stand-up clip drew about 407,000 views in eight hours as a teenager's question took Carr from Freud to falling in love.
"How do you come up with your jokes?!" #jimmycarr #crowdwork #hecklers #standupcomedy
Up next
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 816,562 views a day, 16 times a normal first day on this channel (50,384).
The teenager in the crowd wants to know where Jimmy Carr gets his jokes. He gets an answer about writing them, but he also gets an answer to a question he hasn't asked yet: what if he doesn't know what he wants to do?
Carr starts with curiosity. "Being interesting is downstream of being interested," he says, before talking about reading, comparing jokes to puzzles and bringing up Freud. Then he gets to the work of writing them: "Graft and craft will beat talent every time." That's a different sort of exchange from the quick comebacks that fill some of Carr's most watched Shorts.
When the teenager says he hasn't decided what he wants to do, Carr tells him there's no hurry. He uses geometry to make the point that the subject isn't always what matters most. Learning to give something your attention is a skill in itself, he says, and it matters when you're falling in love, too.
The comments were already far busier than on a usual first day for one of Carr's Shorts. One viewer took up his distinction between choosing what to pay attention to and letting things claim that attention for you.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Comedy & challenges on Trari? Tell us ›
What viewers say
That just summed up the problem I've had all my life. I've never learned to purposefully give things my attention. I've always let things take my attention.
@PerryAhernSee it on YouTubeBro asked for a penny and Jimmy gave him a bill
@michaelthow89See it on YouTubeI love his insightful philosophical answer to such a simple question! That's beautifully artistic!
@WiseOneSunSee it on YouTube
2 more comments
Absolutely brilliant explanation
@jackieslorach1323See it on YouTubeI really admire his kindness here.❤
@Freeflowing1See it on YouTube
Public comments from the video's page on YouTube
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- Jimmy Carr
- Subscribers
- 2,440,000 ▲ 50,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 43,786,817
- Channel views, pace per day
- 3,451,449 (on a normal day: 6,585,638)
- Video published
- November 21, 2026
- Video views so far
- 407,204 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 816,562
The numbers
The Short had already drawn more views in eight hours than Carr's Shorts usually get in a full day.
💡 Test your knowledge
Which school subject does Carr use to explain how we learn to pay attention?
Carr uses geometry to argue that how you study can matter more than what you study.


