Priests confront church harm and their own doubts on ABC
Filmed in 2018, the You Can't Ask That episode brings together clergy whose answers differ on celibacy, scripture and belief.
Why this story? The video opened at a pace of 91,450 views a day, 7.8 times a normal first day on this channel (11,672).
Priests answer the question they dread most | You Can’t Ask That | Full Episode
Next story: Crocs, a crocodile and Mum's lecture on ABC Australia
Things we can learn from the video
Press to jump
- 0:44Participants explain entering ministry through a sense of calling, sometimes after leaving other careers.
- 3:28Answers about sex distinguish celibacy from the married and family lives permitted in other traditions.
- 9:50Clergy differ over biblical literalism, miracles and how religious belief relates to scientific history.
- 12:38The title's central challenge arrives: institutional abuse, power, the Royal Commission and the stigma attached to priesthood.
- 16:38Asked about their churches' moral authority, participants discuss reform, dissent and remaining in ministry.
- 23:33Several describe struggles with belief; Fr Tony Doherty argues that certainty, rather than doubt, is faith's opposite.
Fr Tony Doherty makes room for uncertainty in a programme built around difficult questions. "The opposite of faith is not doubt. It's certainty," the Catholic priest says in ABC Australia's newly uploaded You Can't Ask That episode.
Others describe struggling with doctrine or feeling like a fraud while conducting a service. Their answers come late in an episode that asks not just why someone becomes a priest, but how they can continue representing churches that have harmed people.
Filmed in 2018, the programme brings together Catholic, Anglican, Uniting Church and independent clergy. They read anonymous questions about celibacy, sexuality, biblical miracles and institutional abuse. On scripture, some distinguish religious truth from a literal account of history; others affirm the beliefs at the centre of their faith.
The questions about abuse arrive midway through. Participants discuss power, institutional failures, the Royal Commission and the stigma they encounter wearing a clerical collar. The next question presses the moral issue directly: how can they preach right and wrong given the harm done by their churches? Their responses address reform, dissent and why they remain in ministry.
The upload drew an estimated 91,000 views in its first day, nearly eight times ABC Australia's usual opening for comparable videos. Comments arrived at more than ten times the usual first-day pace.
One recurring viewer request is practical: identify each person's denomination while they answer. Those distinctions matter to discussions of marriage, celibacy and women in ministry, but the episode saves its participant names and church affiliations for the closing cards.
Published on Trari
Where next?
A professional in this field? Want to write about Film & TV on Trari? Tell us ›
What do you think?
Want to know when somebody answers you?
- Channel
- ABC Australia
- Subscribers
- 484,000 ▲ 1,000 this week
- Channel views, last 7 days
- 1,551,807
- Channel views, pace per day
- 309,018 (on a normal day: 263,094)
- Video published
- November 15, 2026
- Video views so far
- 107,708 (less than a day online)
- Video views, pace per day
- 101,970
The numbers
The episode drew an unusually large opening audience for ABC Australia, with an even sharper increase in first-day comments.


